Menu

  • Shepherd’s Pie

    Shepherd’s Pie

    Ground sirloin and diced vegetables in a rich beef sauce, topped with colcannon and cheddar. Served with Irish soda bread. $13.95

  • Fish and Chips

    Fish and Chips

    Lightly battered local fish served with thick-cut chips, tartar sauce and homemade cole slaw. $15.95

  • Corned Beef and Cabbage

    Corned Beef and Cabbage

    Tender corned beef topped with a creamy White Wine-Mustard sauce. Served with red potatoes and buttered cabbage. $15.95

  • Vegetarian Eggs Benedict

    Two freshly poached eggs atop an English muffin with house made Chic pea patty, spinach & garlic, topped with our key lime hollandaise sauce, served with breakfast potatoes. $10.95

  • Irish Eggs Benedict

    Two freshly poached eggs atop an English muffin with rashers, sautéed spinach & garlic, topped with our key lime hollandaise sauce, served with breakfast potatoes. $11.95

  • French Toast

    Hand dipped Texas toast, powdered sugar, fresh fruit and warm maple syrup. $9.95

  • Corned Beef Hash

    Shredded corned beef, breakfast potatoes, drizzled with mustard cream sauce and two eggs sunny-side up.$10.95

  • Hangover Sandwich

    Irish sausages, rashers & a fried egg with cheddar cheese on a texas toast, served with breakfast potatoes. $9.95

  • Breakfast Boxty

    Scrambled eggs, rashers (Irish bacon), fresh tomato, baby spinach, mushroom, with a hint of garlic, rolled up inside a traditional boxty (traditional Potato Crepe) topped with hollandaise, served with breakfast potatoes $11.95

  • Irish Breakfast

    2 Eggs any style, Rashers or Irish Sausage, Toast, and Breakfast Potatoes. $8.95

  • Conch Fritters

    Conch Fritters

    4 fritters served with key lime mustard.

  • Fish Taco

    Fish Taco

    grilled, fried, or blackened served with sour cream and salsa. Add additional tacos for $1.50 ea.

  • Pork Slider

    Pork Slider

    slow cooked in bbq sauce served on mini Kaiser roll. Add additional sliders for $1.50 ea.

  • Mini Irish Nachos

    Mini Irish Nachos

    a new twist on an old favorite, corned beef, melted cheese, shredded lettuce, scallions, diced tomatoes, jalapenos, and a banana pepper. Served with sour cream and salsa.

  • 50 cent Pub Wings (min order of 10)

    50 cent Pub Wings (min order of 10)

    extra plump wings tossed in mild, medium, hot, or Guinness BBQ sauce.

  • Reuben Fritters

    Reuben Fritters

    4 fritters served with Smithwicks aioli.

  • Bone Island Barbeque Pulled Pork

    Bone Island Barbeque Pulled Pork

    Tender shredded slow cooked Pork in a sweet and tangy Guinness BBQ. Served on a Kaiser roll. Comes with thick or thin cut chips or your choice of a side. $12.95

  • McConnell’s Fish Sandwich

    McConnell’s Fish Sandwich

    You cannot leave Key West without trying this famous fish sandwich. Choose from grilled, beer battered or blackened. Served fresh on a Kaiser roll and a side of homemade tartar sauce. Comes with thick or thin cut chips or your choice of a side. $13.95

  • Farmers BLT

    Farmers BLT

    A hearty tradition of rashers, (Irish bacon) or apple wood smoked bacon, vine ripened tomatoes and crisp market lettuce. Comes with thick or thin cut chips or your choice of a side. $10.95

  • BBQ Chicpea Burger

    BBQ Chicpea Burger

    Our house made Chicpea patty seasoned with golden potatoes, red pepper, and spices. Topped with our house made Cole slaw, Red Onion and tangy Guinness BBQ sauce. Comes with thick or thin cut chips or your choice of a side. $10.95

  • Grilled Chicken and Bacon

    Grilled Chicken and Bacon

    Spinach, Cheddar, and our own Key Lime Mustard on Ciabatta bread. Served with your choice of thick or thin cut chips or your choice of side. $13.95

  • The Royal Reuben

    The Royal Reuben

    Tender corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Marie Rose sauce on grilled rye. Comes with thick or thin cut chips or your choice of a side. $13.95

  • Bacon Cheeseburger

    Bacon Cheeseburger

    Grilled to order, topped with melted Cheddar cheese, American, Swiss or Provolone, Rashers (Irish bacon), Lettuce, Tomato and Onion. Comes with thick cut chips or your choice of a side. $13.95

  • House-made Soup of the Day

    House-made Soup of the Day

    Hearty soup made fresh daily served with Irish soda bread $8.95

  • McConnell’s House Salad

    McConnell’s House Salad

    Mixed Greens, Cucumber, Red Onion, vine ripened Tomatoes, Green Peppers and crispy golden brown Croutons. Served with your choice of dressing. $8.95

  • Ceasar Salad

    Ceasar Salad

    Done just the way you like it, with creamy garlic and parmesan dressing and crispy golden brown croutons. Add Chicken $3, Key West Pinks $4, Local Fish of the Day $5 Base Price: $9.95

  • Loaded Potato Skins

    Loaded Potato Skins

    Topped with melted Chedder Cheese, Sour Cream, and Scallions with an option of Rashers or Corned Beef. $8.95

  • Irish Pom Pom Dip

    Irish Pom Pom Dip

    A creamy blend of market fresh ingredients, cream cheese, corned beef, and herbs $8.95

  • Harp Battered Fish Tacos

    Harp Battered Fish Tacos

    With a spicy Chipolte aioli, fresh cabbage, green onion, tomato pico and cilantro. $8.95

  • Chicken Quesadilla

    Chicken Quesadilla

    An Irish twist on an old favorite. Grilled chicken or tender corned beef, tomato pico and melted pepper jack cheese layered between two potato boxties and drizzled with Chipolte aioli and sour cream on the side. $10.95

  • Irish Nachos

    Irish Nachos

    A pot of gold at the end of the rainbow! Golden hand cut potato chips covered with corned beef or grilled chicken, melted cheese, shredded lettuce, scallions, diced tomatoes, jalapenos, and a banana pepper. Served with sour cream and salsa. $11.95

  • Fried Buffalo Shrimp

    Fried Buffalo Shrimp

    Succulent Key West Pink shrimp, battered and fried with a side of mild, medium, or hot sauce. Served with fresh cut celery sticks and a choice of blue cheese or ranch. $11.95

  • Irish Rueben Fritters

    Irish Rueben Fritters

    A classic Rueben in a bite size Fritter. Corned beef, Swiss, and Saurkraut battered to perfection with a pinch of island spice and fried golden brown. Served with Smithwick’s aioli. $11.95

  • Island Conch Fritters

    Island Conch Fritters

    A classic Key West recipe, conch battered to perfection with a pinch of island spice and fried golden brown. Served with Key Lime Mustard sauce. $11.95

  • Slow Roasted Pork Belly

    Slow Roasted Pork Belly

    with a Magners Cider reduction. $7.95

  • Onion Rings

    Onion Rings

    Basket of beer battered and panko crusted fresh cut onion rings. Served with Guinness BBQ and Key Lime Mustard sauce. $8.95

  • Harp Lager Mac and Cheese

    Harp Lager Mac and Cheese

    House made mac and cheese with a Parmesan breadcrumb topping. $9.95

  • Irish Pancakes

    Three large pancakes served with Bailey's whipped cream, butter & warm Bacon Whiskey Maple syrup. Add chocolate chips 10.95

  • $3.50 Smithwicks, Harp, & Bass Drafts!

    You’ve had a long day and we think you need to unwind at the best happy hour in Key West. McConnell’s Irish Pub and Grill’s happy hour features drink specials, the finest European draft beers and a sensational ever-changing food menu. We offer $5 small plates at the southern most Irish bar . Join us Monday – Friday from 4-7 pm for happy hour.

  • Pub Wings

    Pub Wings

    Extra plump wings tossed in your choice of mild, medium, hot, Guinness BBQ sauce or prepared simply key west style, naked. Served with fresh cut celery sticks and a choice of blue cheese or ranch. $11.95

  • Side Items

    Breakfast Potatoes $4.95
    Irish Sausage $3.95
    Rashers (Irish Bacon) $3.95